pickup icon


Welcome to Blue Sheep Bake Shop!


Your holiday treat box includes:

  • Gourmet Gingerbread Cookie: Our soft and chewy Gingerbread cookies use rich spices and a tender texture to elevate your favorite holiday cookie.
  • Gourmet Chocolate Chip Cookie: Our take on a classic, the nutty flavor of brown butter blends perfectly with chocolate chips for a decadent treat.
  • Iced Sugar Cookie with Printed Santa: Hand-cut and carefully iced to perfection, our Printed Sugar Cookies are a hit at every event! This one has an adorable Santa to spread Christmas cheer this season.
  • Gourmet Red Velvet Cupcake: Our Red Velvet sponge cake in cupcake form, iced in  cream cheese buttercream and topped with a red velvet crumb.
  • Chocolate Ganache Macaron: Our creamy, decadent chocolate ganache inside two perfectly-baked almond shells.
  • Vanilla Macaron with Printed NJ Digest Snowflake: Indulge in the elegance of our Vanilla French Macaron, featuring a smooth Vanilla buttercream filling, and a Printed New Jersey Digest logo. These are a favorite of our Corporate clients -- see more examples here!
  • Death by Chocolate Brownie: A rich fudgy brownie base topped with a thick layer of silky chocolate ganache.
  • Assorted chocolates and mints

We'd love for you to drop us a review on Google and FOLLOW US on Instagram!

Allergy info: contains wheat, soy, egg and milk ingredients, may contain traces of peanut and tree nuts (baked in a kitchen which also produces items with peanuts and tree nuts)


Discover the Blue Sheep experience

Discover the sweet magic at Blue Sheep Bake Shop, your go-to destination for exquisite, handcrafted cakes, cupcakes, and pastries. Each of our creations is a fusion of premium ingredients, artistic design, and a dash of love, ensuring a delightful experience with every bite. Specializing in custom cakes for all occasions, we're here to turn your celebrations into memorable events. Located in the heart of our community, Blue Sheep is not just a bake shop, it's a place of joy and delicious artistry. Join us for a taste of happiness!

Explore more of our offerings, from cakes to corporate ordering:

Cake Galleries | Custom Desserts | Corporate Gifting & Catering | Christmas 2023

Hours & About | Submit an Inquiry (Contact Us)

Shop our collections