Homemade Ice Cream in Somerville, NJ
Looking for homemade ice cream in Somerville, NJ? Welcome to Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery, our downtown Somerville bakery and ice cream shop serving handcrafted ice cream, rotating flavors, cones, sundaes, milkshakes, ice cream tacos, ice cream cakes and more.
Our ice cream is made in-house and our flavor case changes throughout the year, mixing classic favorites with creative Blue Sheep flavors and seasonal specials.
Homemade Ice Cream in Downtown Somerville
At Blue Sheep, ice cream isn't an afterthought. Our creamery is part of what we do every day. We make our own hard ice cream and serve a rotating selection of flavors from our ice cream counter at our shop on West Main Street in downtown Somerville.
Some flavors are classic, some are seasonal, and some are a little more Blue Sheep. You'll find everything from chocolate, vanilla and cookies & cream to flavors inspired by bakery desserts, cookies, peanut butter, pistachio, Italian pastries and whatever delicious idea we decide we absolutely need to turn into ice cream next.
Because our ice cream is produced in small batches and flavors rotate, the selection in our case can change. If you have your heart set on a particular flavor, give us a call before visiting to check current availability.
Our Rotating Homemade Ice Cream Flavors
We feature 20 homemade ice cream flavors in our case at a time, with a mix of classics, Blue Sheep favorites and rotating specialty flavors. The lineup changes regularly, so not every flavor listed below is available every day.
If you're visiting our Somerville ice cream shop for a specific flavor, give us a call before you come in to check today's selection.
Looking for a specific flavor?
Our case changes regularly. Call us at
(908) 393-1824
to ask what's scooping today.
Ice Cream Sundaes
Build a classic sundae or watch for our rotating specialty sundaes. Our sundae menu combines homemade ice cream with toppings, sauces, whipped cream and bakery-inspired additions that change with the season.
We also create limited-time weekend specials, so there is usually a perfectly reasonable excuse to come back and see what we're making next.
Milkshakes Made With Homemade Ice Cream
Turn your favorite Blue Sheep ice cream into a thick, creamy milkshake. Choose from available hard ice cream flavors or ask our team about current specialty shake options.
Ice Cream Tacos
Yes, we said ice cream tacos. Our waffle-style ice cream tacos combine scoops of homemade ice cream with toppings, sauces and plenty of unnecessary-but-completely-justified dessert drama.
Specialty taco flavors and four-packs may be offered as rotating or seasonal specials. Follow Blue Sheep on social media or stop in to see what's available.
Soft Serve Ice Cream
In addition to our homemade hard ice cream, ask about our current soft serve flavors. Soft serve availability and flavors may change, so check with the shop for the current selection.
Ice Cream Pints To Go
Need ice cream at home? Grab available flavors by the pint and deal with the difficult decision of whether or not you're actually going to share it.
Ice Cream Cakes Made With Our Homemade Ice Cream
Blue Sheep also creates one of our largest specialty collections: ice cream cakes. Our ice cream cakes are made with our own homemade ice cream and are available in a variety of designs for birthdays, celebrations and special occasions.
Shop Ice Cream CakesCustom Ice Cream Sandwiches
Planning a birthday, wedding, graduation, company event or party? Our custom ice cream sandwiches combine soft-baked cookies, homemade ice cream and your choice of toppings. Each sandwich is individually wrapped, making them an easy grab-and-go dessert for events.
Explore Custom Ice Cream SandwichesYour Downtown Somerville Ice Cream Shop
Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery is located at 84 W Main Street in downtown Somerville, New Jersey. We're a bakery and ice cream shop under one roof, so one person can order a scoop while someone else grabs a cupcake, brownie, French macaron, coffee drink or another bakery treat.
Our downtown Somerville location is convenient for customers visiting from Somerville, Bridgewater, Raritan, Bound Brook, Branchburg, Hillsborough and communities throughout Somerset County.
We're also surrounded by downtown Somerville's restaurants, shops and events, making Blue Sheep an easy dessert stop before or after dinner, during a day downtown or while attending one of Somerville's seasonal events.
Visit Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery
84 W Main Street
Somerville, NJ 08876
Tuesday–Thursday: 11 AM–8 PM
Friday–Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday: 11 AM–6 PM
Monday: Closed
Phone: (908) 393-1824
Walk-ins are welcome during regular business hours.
Hours & Bakery InformationHomemade Ice Cream FAQ
Where can I get homemade ice cream in Somerville, NJ?
Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery serves homemade ice cream at 84 W Main Street in downtown Somerville, New Jersey. Our ice cream counter features rotating flavors along with cones, sundaes, milkshakes and other frozen desserts.
Does Blue Sheep make its own ice cream?
Yes. We make our own hard ice cream and use it throughout our creamery menu, including scoops, milkshakes, sundaes, ice cream cakes and custom ice cream sandwiches.
What ice cream flavors does Blue Sheep have?
Our flavor selection rotates. You'll find classic flavors along with Blue Sheep specialty flavors, bakery-inspired creations and seasonal releases. Because availability changes, contact the shop if you're looking for one particular flavor.
Does Blue Sheep sell ice cream cakes?
Yes. We offer an extensive collection of ice cream cakes made with our homemade ice cream. Ice cream cakes can be ordered in advance through our website.
Can I get ice cream to go?
Yes. Available ice cream can be enjoyed in cups and cones, and pints may be available for take-home purchase. Availability varies by flavor.
Is Blue Sheep only an ice cream shop?
No. Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery is both a bakery and ice cream shop. In addition to homemade ice cream, we offer custom cakes, signature cakes, cupcakes, French macarons, cookies, brownies, dessert bars, coffee drinks and other rotating bakery treats.
Is Blue Sheep located in downtown Somerville?
Yes. Blue Sheep is located at 84 W Main Street in downtown Somerville, NJ, in the heart of Somerset County.