*******CAKES BOOKED THROUGH 1/27/26, ICE CREAM CAKES THROUGH 1/27/26*****

Decorated Sugar Cookies

Make any celebration extra memorable with decorated sugar cookies from Blue Sheep Bake Shop—hand-iced, detail-rich cookies that double as the perfect edible party favor and a standout addition to any dessert table. Available in custom themes, colors, and designs for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, graduations, and corporate events in Somerville, NJ and surrounding areas.

Pink baby shower sugar cookies featuring a baby bottle, angel-wing onesie, rattle, bows, and floral accents made by Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Pink Baby Shower Sugar Cookie Set | Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Cross Decorated Sugar Cookies

Birthday sugar cookies featuring Happy Birthday script, milestone messaging, and candle designs made by Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Fabulous 21st Birthday Sugar Cookie Set | Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Here comes the son baby shower cookie favors with onesies and bottles in Somerville NJ

Here Comes The Son Baby Shower Cookie Favors

Pink wizard-themed sugar cookies with gold lightning bolts, wand designs, and magical details made by Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Pink Harry Potter Themed Sugar Cookies

Custom "Tinis and Weenies" 21st birthday cookie favors with martini glasses, pink and green designs, and playful details by Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville, NJ.

Tini's and Weenies 21st Birthday Cookie Favors

Pink and purple butterfly-themed baby shower cookies with onesie and "A Little Butterfly is on the Way" designs.

"A Little Butterfly" Baby Shower Cookie Set

Baptism and christening custom sugar cookies with cross and God Bless designs from Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Initial Baptism & Christening Custom Cookies Set

Pink baby shower sugar cookies with personalized name, welcome little one message, florals, and gold accents by Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Sofia's Pink Baby Shower Custom Cookies

Bride and groom heart-shaped wedding sugar cookies with royal icing and elegant tuxedo and lace designs from Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Bride & Groom Wedding Heart Cookies | Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Alice in Wonderland themed custom sugar cookies with teacups and characters by Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

Alice in Wonderland Custom Cookies

Teddy Bear First Birthday Cookies | Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Somerville NJ

1
2
3
…
9