Custom Ice Cream Sandwiches
Looking for a dessert that's a little more fun than the usual cupcakes or cookies? Our custom ice cream sandwiches are made with our special soft-baked cookies, our homemade ice cream, and your choice of toppings for a dessert that's perfect for birthdays, weddings, showers, corporate events, employee celebrations, graduations, and parties.
Made by Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery in Somerville, NJ, each ice cream sandwich is individually wrapped, making them easy to serve, display, hand out, or include as part of an event dessert spread.
Minimum order: 36 custom ice cream sandwiches.
Build Your Custom Ice Cream Sandwiches
Choose your cookies, ice cream flavors, and toppings to create a combination that fits your event. Keep it classic, mix and match flavors, or coordinate your sandwiches with your party colors or theme.
Cookie Options
Choose one cookie flavor for every 18 ice cream sandwiches ordered. For example, an order of 36 sandwiches can include up to two cookie flavors.
Soft Chocolate Sandwich Cookie
A classic chocolate cookie made specifically to stay soft when frozen.
Pairs well with: Vanilla, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate, Mint Chip, and Coffee.
Soft Chocolate Chip Cookie
A soft-baked chocolate chip cookie made with mini chocolate chips for an easy bite straight from the freezer.
Pairs well with: Vanilla, Cookie Dough, Birthday Cake, Cookies & Cream, and Chocolate.
Fudgy Brownie Cookie
A rich, chocolatey brownie-style cookie with a soft, fudgy texture.
Pairs well with: Vanilla, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Coffee.
Funfetti Soft Sugar Cookie
A soft sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles baked right in. This one is especially fun for birthdays, showers, celebrations, and colorful corporate events.
Pairs well with: Birthday Cake, Vanilla, Strawberry, and Cake Batter.
Soft Oatmeal Cookie
A soft and chewy oatmeal cookie with a warm cinnamon flavor.
Pairs well with: Vanilla, Salted Caramel, Coffee, and other warm or spiced ice cream flavors.
Red Velvet Cookie
A soft red velvet cookie with a light cocoa flavor and beautiful rich color.
Pairs well with: Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry.
Ice Cream Flavors
Choose one ice cream flavor for every 12 sandwiches ordered. That means our 36-sandwich minimum can include up to three different ice cream flavors.
Vanilla
Classic, creamy, and crowd-friendly. Vanilla works beautifully with almost every cookie and topping combination.
Cookies & Cream
One of our favorite crowd-pleasers and a great choice for corporate events, parties, and large groups.
Birthday Cake
Fun and colorful with plenty of celebration vibes. Especially good with Funfetti or Chocolate Chip cookies.
Chocolate
Rich and classic. Pair it with Chocolate, Brownie, Chocolate Chip, or Red Velvet cookies.
Cookie Dough
Pair Cookie Dough ice cream with our Chocolate Chip Cookie for the ultimate cookie-on-cookie ice cream sandwich.
Strawberry
Bright and fruity. Strawberry pairs especially well with Funfetti, Red Velvet, Brownie, and Chocolate cookies.
Coffee
A slightly more grown-up ice cream sandwich option that pairs beautifully with Chocolate, Brownie, and Oatmeal cookies.
Salted Caramel
Rich, sweet, and a little salty. Try it with Oatmeal, Chocolate Chip, or Chocolate cookies.
Mint Chip
A classic pairing with our Soft Chocolate Sandwich Cookie.
Peanut Butter
Rich and creamy and especially good with Brownie, Chocolate, or Chocolate Chip cookies.
Cake Batter
Pair Cake Batter ice cream with our Funfetti Soft Sugar Cookie for a birthday-cake-inspired ice cream sandwich.
Ice Cream Sandwich Toppings
Take them one step further by having the exposed ice cream edges rolled in a topping. Available options include:
- Rainbow Sprinkles
- Chocolate Sprinkles
- Mini Chocolate Chips
- Biscoff Cookie Crumbles
- Chopped Oreos
- Reese's Pieces
- Specialty Colored Sprinkles
Planning an event with a specific color palette? Ask about specialty colored sprinkles that coordinate with your birthday, shower, wedding, corporate event, school colors, or party theme.
Custom Ice Cream Sandwiches for Parties & Events
Custom ice cream sandwiches are an easy individual dessert option for events because every sandwich arrives individually wrapped. There's no slicing, scooping, or plating required.
They're a great option for:
- Corporate events and employee appreciation
- Company picnics and office parties
- Birthdays
- Weddings and wedding weekends
- Bridal showers and baby showers
- Graduation parties
- School events
- Bar and Bat Mitzvahs
- Family celebrations
- Client gifts and branded events
Ordering Information
- Minimum order: 36 ice cream sandwiches
- Cookie selections: One cookie flavor per 18 sandwiches
- Ice cream selections: One ice cream flavor per 12 sandwiches
- Packaging: Each ice cream sandwich is individually wrapped
- Toppings: Choose from sprinkles, cookie crumbles, mini chocolate chips, Reese's Pieces, and other available options
- Custom colors: Specialty sprinkle colors can be selected to coordinate with many events and celebrations
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the minimum order for custom ice cream sandwiches?
Our minimum order is 36 custom ice cream sandwiches.
Can I order more than one cookie flavor?
Yes. You can choose one cookie flavor for every 18 sandwiches. An order of 36 sandwiches, for example, can include two different cookie flavors.
Can I order more than one ice cream flavor?
Yes. You can choose one ice cream flavor for every 12 sandwiches. An order of 36 sandwiches can therefore include up to three different ice cream flavors.
Are the ice cream sandwiches individually wrapped?
Yes. Each sandwich is individually wrapped, making them especially convenient for parties, corporate events, celebrations, and large gatherings.
Can the ice cream sandwiches match my event colors?
Absolutely. Specialty colored sprinkles can be used to coordinate the sandwiches with many event color palettes and themes.
Where can I order custom ice cream sandwiches in New Jersey?
Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery creates custom ice cream sandwiches in Somerville, New Jersey. Contact us with your event date, quantity, and flavor ideas and we'll help you plan your order.
Ready to Create Your Ice Cream Sandwiches?
Whether you're planning a birthday party, wedding, corporate event, shower, graduation, or just need an excuse to order a few dozen ice cream sandwiches, we'd love to help.
Start with a minimum of 36 sandwiches and choose your cookies, ice cream flavors, and toppings to create your custom combination.
Contact Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery to start planning your custom ice cream sandwich order.