Thanksgiving pre-orders are open for pickup on 11/25. Signature & Ice cream cakes booked through 12/1
Bakery FAQ | Cakes, Cupcakes, French Macarons, Ice Cream & Drinks in Somerville, NJ
Looking for custom cakes, birthday cakes, homemade ice cream, cupcakes, French macarons, dirty sodas, specialty lattes, or desserts in Somerville, NJ? Find answers to common questions about visiting Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery, ordering celebration cakes, and enjoying our bakery and ice cream shop at 84 W Main Street in downtown Somerville.
Visit Our Somerville Bakery & Ice Cream Shop
Where is Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery located?
We are located at 84 W Main Street, Somerville, NJ 08876, in downtown Somerville, Somerset County. We moved from our former location and are excited to welcome customers to our expanded bakery and creamery.
What are your bakery hours?
Monday: Closed
Tuesday–Thursday: 11 AM–8 PM
Friday–Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday: 11 AM–6 PM
Holiday and special event hours may vary.
Can I visit without ordering in advance?
Absolutely! Walk-ins are always welcome! Stop by for freshly stocked bakery desserts, grab-and-go birthday cakes, homemade ice cream, dirty sodas, specialty lattes, and other delicious treats.
Custom cake designs and specialty orders require advance ordering, but you never need an excuse to stop in for dessert!
What do you sell at Blue Sheep Bake Shop?
Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery offers a wide selection of freshly made desserts and specialty beverages, including:
- Custom birthday cakes and wedding cakes
- Signature Cakes and grab-and-go cakes
- 20 rotating flavors of homemade ice cream
- Ice cream cakes, milkshakes, and sundaes
- Gourmet cupcakes and French macarons
- Decorated sugar cookies and gourmet cookies
- Brownies, dessert bars, and cheesecakes
- Dirty sodas and specialty iced lattes
- Espresso drinks and gourmet hot chocolate
- Seasonal desserts and specialty treats
Our bakery cases and menus change seasonally, so there's always something new to discover!
Homemade Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts
Is your ice cream homemade?
Yes! Our ice cream is homemade! At Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery, we make our own artisan ice cream and feature 20 rotating flavors at our Somerville ice cream counter.
Our selection features classic favorites, creative specialty flavors, and delicious seasonal creations.
What ice cream flavors do you offer?
We feature 20 rotating flavors of homemade ice cream. Our selection changes regularly and may include favorites such as:
- Vanilla and Chocolate
- Oreo
- Cookie Dough
- Italian Rainbow Cookie
- Banana Bread
- Pistachio
- Coffee Fudge
- Brownie-inspired flavors
- Pumpkin Biscoff and other seasonal specialties
Visit our Somerville ice cream shop to discover our current lineup. Flavors are subject to availability.
Do you sell milkshakes, sundaes, and ice cream cakes?
Absolutely! We offer milkshakes, sundaes, and ice cream cakes made with our homemade ice cream.
We also stock ready-to-purchase ice cream cakes when available. For a particular size, flavor, or design, we recommend ordering ahead.
Dirty Sodas, Specialty Lattes & Hot Chocolate
What is a dirty soda?
A dirty soda is a fun and flavorful twist on traditional soda! We combine popular sodas with flavored syrups and our signature sweet cream topping to create a refreshing, creamy, fizzy treat.
Our dirty sodas are non-alcoholic and made fresh to order.
What dirty soda flavors do you serve?
Our specialty dirty soda menu features creative combinations including:
- Dirty Dr Pepper OG
- Dirty Shirley
- Butter Beer
- Cherry Vanilla Crush
- Passion Dragon Dazzle
- Seasonal and limited-edition flavors
All drinks are made fresh to order. Flavors and seasonal offerings may change.
Do you serve iced lattes and espresso drinks?
Yes! Our specialty coffee menu features handcrafted iced lattes, espresso drinks, and creative flavor combinations.
Popular latte flavors include:
- Nutella
- Cookie Butter
- Toasted Marshmallow
- S'mores
- Brown Sugar
- Salted Caramel
- Death by Chocolate
- Cinnabun
- Butterbeer
Milk alternatives and add-ons, including extra espresso shots, are available.
Do you offer hot chocolate and white hot chocolate?
Yes! We serve gourmet hot chocolate, creamy white hot chocolate, and specialty flavored hot chocolate creations.
Our hot chocolate is prepared with steamed milk for a deliciously smooth, rich texture.
Looking for something extra? Ask about adding espresso to create a dirty hot chocolate!
Seasonal flavors and toppings may vary.
What is an affogato?
An affogato is a delicious combination of ice cream and espresso! Freshly brewed espresso is poured over ice cream, creating a rich, creamy dessert.
We offer classic and specialty affogato creations featuring our homemade ice cream.
Custom Cakes & Birthday Cakes in Somerville, NJ
What is the difference between a custom cake and a Signature Cake?
Custom Cakes are individually designed for your occasion. They may feature detailed decorations, custom colors, themes, fondant artwork, or elaborate buttercream designs.
Signature Cakes are a curated collection of our most popular decorated buttercream cakes available to order online. They provide a convenient and more budget-friendly alternative to fully custom cake designs.
What kinds of custom cakes do you create?
We specialize in custom cakes for:
- Birthdays and milestone celebrations
- Weddings and engagement parties
- Baby showers and bridal showers
- Graduations
- Communions, confirmations, and baptisms
- Anniversaries
- Corporate celebrations
- Other special occasions
From elegant buttercream cakes to elaborate themed creations, we love bringing your ideas to life!
How do I request a custom cake quote?
The best way to request custom cake pricing is by completing our Custom Cake Quote Request Form .
Please include your event date, number of servings, design inspiration, and any other relevant details. Inspiration photos are especially helpful!
Once we review your request, we'll discuss pricing and availability.
Your cake is not officially booked until payment has been processed and your order is confirmed.
How far in advance should I order a custom cake?
We recommend requesting custom cakes 2–4 weeks in advance, especially during busy celebration seasons.
Signature Cakes can often be ordered with approximately 7–10 days' notice, depending on our production schedule.
Availability and order cutoffs may vary, and ordering may close earlier when we reach capacity.
How much does a custom cake cost?
Custom cake pricing depends on the cake's size, number of servings, design complexity, decorations, and flavors.
For an accurate price, please complete our Custom Cake Quote Request Form.
Looking for something more budget-friendly? Explore our Signature Cake Collection .
Do you have birthday cakes available for same-day pickup?
Yes! Our Somerville bakery regularly stocks grab-and-go birthday cakes that are ready for purchase.
Our grab-and-go cake selection commonly includes 5-inch and 7-inch decorated cakes.
Designs, flavors, sizes, and quantities vary daily. Visit our bakery to see what's available!
Can you recreate a cake from an inspiration photo?
We welcome inspiration photos, party invitations, color palettes, and design ideas!
However, every decorator has a unique artistic style. We interpret designs in our own signature style and cannot guarantee exact replicas of another artist's work.
How should I store and transport my cake?
Keep your cake refrigerated until shortly before your event, following any specific instructions provided by our team.
Transport your cake on a flat, level surface inside an air-conditioned vehicle, away from direct sunlight.
Avoid placing cakes on slanted seats or someone's lap. Careful transportation helps protect your cake's decorations and structure.
Online Ordering, Allergies, Delivery & Events
Can I order desserts online for pickup?
Yes! Many of our Signature Cakes, ice cream cakes, cupcakes, cookies, French macarons, and other bakery desserts can be ordered online.
Available pickup dates depend on the product, required preparation time, and our current production schedule.
Shop Blue Sheep Bake Shop Online and review the selected pickup date at checkout.
Do you offer gluten-sensitive or dairy-free desserts?
Yes! We offer gluten-sensitive cakes and cupcakes, French macarons made without gluten-containing ingredients in their standard recipes, and rotating dairy-free ice cream options.
Important: Our bakery is not an allergen-free facility. We handle wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and other common allergens. Cross-contact is possible.
Please discuss food allergies and dietary restrictions with our staff before purchasing.
Do you make custom cookies, cupcakes, and party favors?
Absolutely! We create decorated sugar cookies, printed logo cookies, cupcakes, French macarons, and other specialty dessert favors.
These are perfect for birthdays, weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, graduations, corporate events, and other celebrations.
Do you offer corporate desserts and large orders?
Yes! We work with businesses, event planners, schools, and organizations on corporate dessert orders, branded cookies, boxed sweets, cupcakes, and specialty favors.
Whether you're planning an employee appreciation event, corporate celebration, product launch, or special promotion, we'd love to help!
Do you offer cake and dessert delivery?
Delivery may be available for custom cakes, specialty orders, and corporate events.
Pricing and availability depend on location, order details, and our schedule.
Retail dessert delivery may also be available through participating third-party delivery platforms. Please contact us for details.
Can I change or cancel my cake order?
Because our cakes and specialty desserts are made to order, changes and cancellations depend on the terms accepted when your order was booked.
Please review our Custom Order Contract for applicable policies.
Contact us as soon as possible if you need assistance with an existing order.
How can I contact Blue Sheep Bake Shop?
Blue Sheep Bake Shop & Creamery
84 W Main Street
Somerville, NJ 08876
Phone: (908) 393-1824
Email: orders@bluesheepbakeshop.com
For custom cake pricing, please complete our Custom Cake Quote Request Form .
Come for the cake. Stay for the ice cream. Leave with more desserts than you planned.
