pickup icon

******* PLEASE READ - CAKES ARE BOOKED UNTIL JULY 15! *******

Custom Specialty Cake Flavors

 At Blue Sheep we believe cakes should taste as good as they look - and that's why we bake everything immediately before the event with top of the line ingredients and never freeze our cakes. Our birthday cakes and custom cakes are fresh, moist, and rich in flavor.  

Signature birthday cakes & celebration cakes are available in vanilla cake, chocolate cake, birthday cake, red velvet cake, or Oreo cake. Cake filling choices are vanilla buttercream, chocolate buttercream, strawberry buttercream, cream cheese, Oreo buttercream, and vanilla & chocolate mousse by special request. 

GF - available in gluten free cake, however we are not a gluten free facility. Gluten free is baked in the same over as our gluten based items and  we cannot guarantee there will be no cross contamination. 

Custom Cake Options Custom Cake Filling Options
Cake Choices
  • Almond (& GF)
  • Apple Spice 
  • Banana (& GF)
  • Birthday (& GF)
  • Carrot
  • Champagne*
  • Chocolate (& GF)
  • Chocolate Chip (& GF)
  • Coconut (& GF)
  • Cookies and Cream (& GF
  • Cookie Dough
  • Honey Cinnamon (& GF)
  • Lavender*
  • Lemon
  • Pecan (seasonal/premium +$1/serving)
  • Pear Spice
  • Pink Velvet*
  • Pina Colada*
  • Pumpkin
  • Red Velvet
  • Strawberry
  • Yellow Vanilla (& GF)
  • White Vanilla

 

 

    European Butter Cream fillings:

    • Almond Buttercream (& GF)
    • Caramel Buttercream (& GF)
    • Chocolate Buttercream (& GF)
    • Chocolate Mousse
    • Cookie Dough Buttercream
    • Espresso Buttercream
    • Lemon Buttercream (& GF)
    • Mint Buttercream 
    • Mocha
    • Oreos & Cream Buttercream (& GF)
    • Peanut Butter Buttercream (& GF)
    • Raspberry Buttercream
    • Strawberry Buttercream
    • Vanilla Buttercream (& GF)
    • Vanilla Mousse

     

           

            Premium Fillings $1 extra per serving

            • Cream Cheese
            • Nutella Buttercream
            • Guava Cream & Swirl
            • Pear Spice
            • Chocolate Ganache (& GF)
            • Cannoli Cream (& GF)
            • Strawberry Preserve Swirl
            • Raspberry Preserve Swirl
            • Cookie Dough Pieces
            * indicates premium cakes available at an extra cost