Custom Cake Flavors

Discover the Best Cake & Filling Combinations | Blue Sheep Bake Shop

At Blue Sheep Bake Shop, we believe every cake should taste as amazing as it looks! Whether you're planning a birthday, wedding, anniversary, or corporate event, choosing the perfect cake and filling pairing is essential. From timeless classics like Red Velvet with Cream Cheese to gourmet flavors like Chocolate Chip Cake with Nutella Buttercream & Nutella Swirl, we offer a wide selection of custom cake flavors to satisfy every craving.

See our recommendations for Unique Cake Flavor Combinations!

GF - available in gluten free cake - we are not a gluten free facility. Gluten-free products are baked in the same ovens as our AP flour desserts and we can't guarantee there will be no cross contamination. 

Our handcrafted cakes are made with premium ingredients, and each layer is carefully paired with buttercreams, mousses, curds, and ganaches to create a flavor experience like no other. Whether you prefer a rich and decadent Chocolate Cake with Salted Caramel Filling, a light and fruity Lemon Cake with Raspberry Preserves, or a unique blend like Pistachio Cake with Honey Buttercream, we’ve got something delicious for you.

Explore Our Cake & Fillings Guide Below & Build Your Dream Cake Today!

Looking for the best cake and filling pairings? Whether you're baking a wedding cake, birthday cake, or custom dessert, the right cake and filling combination can make all the difference! Here are 25 delicious cake and filling ideas to inspire your next bake:

Classic Cake and Filling Pairings

• Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Filling – A classic Southern favorite with rich, velvety cake and a tangy, creamy filling.
• Chocolate Cake with Salted Caramel Filling – A decadent mix of deep chocolate and gooey salted caramel.
• Lemon Cake with Raspberry Filling – A bright, tangy citrus cake perfectly balanced by sweet raspberry buttercream & raspberry preserves.
• Vanilla Cake with Strawberry Buttercream – A delicate and fruity pairing, ideal for wedding cakes and birthday celebrations.
• Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Filling – A spiced cake paired with smooth, tangy cream cheese frosting.
• Birthday Cake with Oreo Buttercream Filling – A classic yellow vanilla cake brimming with rainbow sprinkles and filled with Oreo buttercream filling & crushed oreos
• Chocolate Chip Cake with Cookie Dough & Vanilla Cream - A buttercream white vanilla cake baked with mini chocolate chips that melt in your mouth, filled with vanilla Swiss buttercream and cookie dough.

Decadent & Indulgent Cake Fillings

• Chocolate Cake with Espresso Buttercream – A bold blend of mocha and chocolate, perfect for coffee lovers.
• Mocha Cake with Bailey’s Buttercream – A sophisticated cake infused with espresso and Irish cream liqueur.
• Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Buttercream and Chocolate Ganache – A peanut butter lover’s dream, featuring smooth chocolate ganache.
• Marble Cake with Chocolate Ganache – A mix of vanilla and chocolate swirls topped with rich ganache.
• Cookies and Cream Cake with Oreo Buttercream – A nostalgic favorite, featuring crushed Oreo cookies.

Unique & Gourmet Cake Flavor Combinations

• Pistachio Cake with Honey Buttercream – A nutty, lightly sweet cake with a floral honey finish.
• Lavender cake with Earl Grey Tea Buttercream – A sophisticated tea-infused cake, great for brunch desserts.
• Champagne Cake with Strawberry Filling – A bubbly, light cake infused with real champagne and a fruity strawberry filling.
• Coconut Cake with Guava Cream & Preserve – A tropical combination that brings the flavors of summer to your cake.
• Spice Cake with Maple Buttercream – A cozy fall cake flavor, featuring warm spices and sweet maple frosting.

Nutty & Fruity Cake Filling Ideas

• Chocolate Chip Cake with Nutella Buttercream & Nutella Swirl – A buttery white vanilla cake, studed with chocolate chips & filled with nutty Nutella filling
• Pina Colada Cake filled with Coconut Buttercream  – A Piña Colada-inspired cake bursting with tropical flavors.
• Almond Cake with Raspberry Preserve Swirl – A nutty, fruity pairing that’s both elegant and delicious.
• Banana Cake with Cream Cheese Filling – A moist banana-flavored cake with a tangy cream cheese complement.
• Almond Cake with Amaretto Buttercream – A rich, Italian-inspired cake with the flavors of almond liqueur.

Best Cake Fillings for Weddings & Special Events

• Lemon Cake with Lemon Buttercream – A bright, citrusy option that’s refreshing and light.
• Funfetti Cake with Vanilla Buttercream – A playful, festive cake, perfect for birthdays.
• Coconut Cake with Nutella Buttercream – A mix of tropical coconut and creamy Nutella.
• Chocolate Cake with Salted Caramel Filling – A luxurious combination with a sweet and salty contrast. 
  

Which Cake and Filling Pairing Will You Try?

Looking for a custom cake flavor for your next event? These cake and filling ideas are perfect for weddings, birthdays, and special occasions.