pickup icon

Thanksgiving pre-orders are open for pickup on 11/25. Signature & Ice cream cakes booked through 12/1

Custom Cake Galleries & FAQS

Looking for custom cakes in Somerville, NJ? At Blue Sheep Bake Shop, we specialize in beautifully designed custom birthday cakes, wedding cakes, baby shower cakes, bridal shower cakes, graduation cakes, and specialty celebration cakes. Located in downtown Somerville in Somerset County, New Jersey, our bakery creates made-to-order cakes that bring your ideas, colors, and celebrations to life.

Whether you're planning a milestone birthday, an elegant wedding, a themed children's party, or another special occasion, our talented cake decorating team can help create a design that's uniquely yours. Browse our custom cake galleries for inspiration or request a personalized quote.

REQUEST A CUSTOM CAKE QUOTE »

Custom Cake Designs for Every Occasion

Explore our gallery of custom cakes and specialty cake designs. From timeless buttercream finishes to elaborate fondant details, each custom cake is designed around your occasion, style, and serving needs.

Custom Birthday Cakes

Celebrate birthdays of every age with a personalized cake. We create milestone birthday cakes, Sweet 16 cakes, 21st birthday cakes, 30th, 40th, 50th birthday cakes, and beyond. Choose from elegant designs, vintage piping, floral details, and creative themes.

Browse Custom Birthday Cakes »

Children's Birthday Cakes

From whimsical and colorful designs to themed birthday cakes featuring favorite hobbies and interests, our custom children's cakes make birthdays extra special.

Browse Children's Birthday Cakes »

Wedding Cakes

Our custom wedding cakes include romantic buttercream designs, elegant tiered cakes, modern wedding cake styles, and decorative floral details. We work with couples to create cakes that complement their wedding celebration.

Browse Wedding Cakes »

Bridal Shower Cakes

Celebrate the bride-to-be with a custom bridal shower cake. Explore delicate florals, sophisticated buttercream designs, vintage-inspired piping, and personalized celebration cakes.

Browse Bridal Shower Cakes »

Baby Shower and Gender Reveal Cakes

Welcome a new arrival with a beautifully decorated baby shower cake. We create cakes featuring soft colors, elegant florals, playful themes, and personalized details for baby showers and gender reveal celebrations.

Browse Baby Shower Cakes »

Graduation Cakes

Celebrate graduation from high school, college, or another milestone with a custom graduation cake. Incorporate school colors, graduation caps, personal interests, and meaningful details into your design.

Browse Graduation Cakes »

Sculpted Cakes, Groom's Cakes and Cakes for Men

Looking for something creative and unexpected? Our gallery features specialty sculpted cakes, groom's cakes, sports-themed cakes, hobby-inspired designs, and personalized cakes for men.

Browse Sculpted and Groom's Cakes »

Religious Celebration Cakes

Our custom religious celebration cakes are designed for baptisms, christenings, First Communions, confirmations, and other meaningful family celebrations.

Browse Religious Celebration Cakes »

How Much Does a Custom Cake Cost in NJ?

Custom cakes at Blue Sheep Bake Shop start at $325, with a minimum of approximately 15 servings. Our starting custom cake size is a 7-inch round.

Custom cake pricing depends on the number of servings, design complexity, cake size, decorative details, and specialty elements. Every custom cake is individually quoted based on the design requested.

For a more budget-friendly celebration cake, explore our Signature Cake Collection, starting at $54.95. These designs can be ordered directly through our website, subject to availability.

Shop Signature Cakes »

GET PRICING FOR YOUR CUSTOM CAKE »

How to Order a Custom Cake

Ordering a custom cake from Blue Sheep Bake Shop begins with our online quote request form.

  1. Browse our cake galleries. Explore our previous designs to find inspiration for your celebration or submit inspiration pics via our custom cake request form .
  2. Submit a custom cake quote request. Include your event date, serving count, design preferences, and inspiration photos whenever possible.
  3. Review your design and pricing. Our cake team will review your request and discuss available options.
  4. Finalize your order. Once the design, flavors, and payment have been finalized, our staff will confirm your booking.

REQUEST YOUR CUSTOM CAKE QUOTE »

Custom Cake Flavors and Fillings

A beautiful cake should taste just as wonderful as it looks. Explore our available custom cake flavors and fillings to help create the perfect cake for your celebration. Flavor options and availability may vary.

Explore Custom Cake Flavors »

Custom Cake Ordering Policies

Please review our ordering guidelines before requesting your custom cake.

  • Advance notice: Custom cakes generally require 2 to 6 weeks of advance booking, depending on our availability and the complexity of the design.
  • Order confirmation: Your cake is officially booked only after the design, flavors, and payment are finalized and you receive confirmation from our staff.
  • Payment: Full payment is required at the time of booking.
  • Design and size changes: Changes may be requested up to 15 days before the scheduled order date.
  • Cancellations: Cancellation requests may be submitted up to 15 days before the scheduled order date, subject to our applicable order policies.
  • Delivery: Delivery is available, with pricing based on location.
  • Response times: Our decorating team has very limited phone and email availability on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays while preparing customer orders. We appreciate your patience during these busy production days.

Custom Cakes Near Somerville, Bridgewater and Somerset County, NJ

Blue Sheep Bake Shop is located at 84 W Main Street, Somerville, NJ 08876, in the heart of downtown Somerville.

We welcome custom cake inquiries from customers in Somerville, Bridgewater, Hillsborough, Bound Brook, Basking Ridge, Warren, Bernardsville, Bedminster, and surrounding Somerset County communities and throughout the state of NJ. We also service Manhattan, NYC, Easter PA, and Southern CT. We also work with customers planning celebrations throughout New Jersey, NYC, parts of PA and CT.

Whether you're searching for a custom birthday cake near Bridgewater, a wedding cake in Somerset County, or a specialty cake bakery in Somerville, explore our gallery and submit your ideas for a personalized quote.

Frequently Asked Questions About Custom Cakes

Where can I order a custom birthday cake in Somerville, NJ?

Blue Sheep Bake Shop creates custom birthday cakes and specialty celebration cakes at our bakery at 84 W Main Street in downtown Somerville, NJ. Browse our cake galleries and submit a quote request to begin planning your cake.

How far in advance should I order a custom cake?

We recommend contacting us 2 to 6 weeks before your event, depending on the complexity of your cake and our availability. Popular weekends and holiday periods may book earlier.

What is the minimum price for a custom cake?

Custom cakes start at $325 with a minimum of approximately 15 servings. Final pricing depends on the size, decorations, and details requested.

Do you make custom wedding and shower cakes?

Yes! We create custom cakes for weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, engagement parties, and other celebrations. Browse our galleries for design inspiration.

Do you offer smaller birthday cakes?

Yes. Our Signature Cake Collection offers ready-to-order designs starting at $54.95. These cakes are a convenient alternative to a fully custom cake.

Can I order an ice cream cake instead?

Absolutely! Blue Sheep Bake Shop also offers ice cream cakes and pies that can be ordered through our online store.

Shop Ice Cream Cakes and Pies »

Do you offer cake delivery?

Delivery is available for qualifying orders. Pricing and availability depend on the delivery location and order details. Please include your delivery address when requesting a quote.

Let's Create Something Special for Your Celebration

From elegant wedding cakes and personalized birthday cakes to whimsical children's cakes and milestone celebrations, Blue Sheep Bake Shop loves bringing creative cake ideas to life.

Visit our bakery in downtown Somerville, NJ, browse our custom cake galleries, and tell us about your next celebration. We look forward to creating something special for you.

REQUEST A CUSTOM CAKE QUOTE »

Blue Sheep Bake Shop
84 W Main Street
Somerville, NJ 08876
Phone: (908) 393-1824
Email: orders@bluesheepbakeshop.com