Skip to content

******* PLEASE READ - SIGNATURE CAKES ARE BOOKED UNTIL December 3rd *******

Loading...

Home
Thanksgiving Dessert
Inquiry Form
Custom Cakes
Shop Signature, Gluten-Free, & Ice Cream Cakes
Cupcakes, French Macarons, Cookies, & More!
FAQ's
Hours/About
Party Planning
Chefin' With The Sheep - Custom Cake Adventures
Employment Application
Account

Home
/ Decorated Sugar Cookies

Decorated Sugar Cookies

Decorated sugar cookies are an excellent choice for a party favor or as a compliment to your dessert table!

Filter by

Clear

Availability

Availability

61 results

Clear

In stock 58
Out of stock 3

Price

Price

61 results

Clear

$

–

$

Sort by Featured

Sort by

Featured
Best Selling
Title, A-Z
Title, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new

Clear all

NJ baby shower printed cookie favors, with a woodland animal theme, including a skunk, fox, bear, raccoon, and deer.

Christy's Woodland Animal Baby Shower Cookies - Printed

NJ Pixar Cars theme decorated sugar cookie party favors, featuring Lightning McQueen and Tow Mater. KACHOW!

Lightning McQueen & Tow Mater Cookies

NJ wedding We Do decorated sugar cookie favors, with royal icing cursive text and gold luster splatter

We Do Wedding Favor Cookies

NJ customized pumpkin-shaped decorated sugar cookie favors, in blush pink and burgundy colors, for a baby shower. These read "Hello Baby Mishra"

Blush and Burgundy Pumpkin Baby Shower Cookies

NJ astronaut themed printed sugar cookie party favors, featuring watercolor astronauts and rocketships

Watercolor Astronaut & Rocket Ship Cookies - Printed

NJ blue and white floral Sweet 16 printed sugar cookie favors

Emma's Sweet 16 Blue Floral Cookie Favors - Printed

Superhero Emblem' Decorated Cookies

Custom Printed Logo Cookie Favors

Lord of the Rings-themed baby shower cookies with Tree of Gondor, "smallest person" quote, baby onesies, and bottles.

Lord of the Rings Baby Shower Cookies

Adorable crab-shaped cookies with red icing and playful expressions, perfect for beach-themed parties.

Crab Cookie Favors

Pink and purple butterfly-themed baby shower cookies with onesie and "A Little Butterfly is on the Way" designs.

"A Little Butterfly" Baby Shower Cookie Set

Round blush and gold christening cookies with personalized "God Bless" message.

Blush & Gold Christening Cookie Favors

1
…
3
4
5
6

Access Denied

IMPORTANT! If you’re a store owner, please make sure you have Customer accounts enabled in your Store Admin, as you have customer based locks set up with EasyLockdown app. Enable Customer Accounts

Get updates

Contact and Policies

orders@bluesheepbakeshop.com
(908) 393-1824
9 Division St, Somerville NJ
Terms of Service
Refund policy
Sitemap
Custom Order Contract
Signature Cake Contract/Policy

Discover the Blue Sheep experience

Discover Blue Sheep Bake Shop, your go-to destination for exquisite, handcrafted custom cakes, birthday cakes, cupcakes, French macarons, homemade ice cream, and pastries. Each of our cakes and creations is a fusion of premium ingredients, artistic design, and a dash of love, ensuring a delightful experience with every bite. Specializing in custom cakes and birthday cakes for all occasions, we're here to turn your celebrations into memorable events. Located in downtown Somerville NJ, in the heart of Somerset County.

Copyright © 2024 Blue Sheep Bake Shop. Ecommerce Software by Shopify