Skip to content

******* PLEASE READ - CAKES ARE BOOKED UNTIL Jan 20th*******

Loading...

Home
Inquiry Form
Custom Cakes
Order CAKES Online (Signature, Gluten Sensitive, Ice Cream)
Cupcakes, French Macarons, Cookies, & More!
FAQ's
Hours/About
Party Planning
Chefin' With The Sheep - Custom Cake Adventures
Employment Application
Account

Home
/ Thanksgiving Dessert Menu

Thanksgiving Dessert Menu

This year's Thanksgiving collection features traditional pies, ice cream pies, and even - cookie pies! We are also excited to launch our first Thanksgiving Gobble Box, perfect for the kiddies!

----PICK UP IS WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER 24TH ----

You can also order from our bakery take out menu which includes gourmet cupcakes, macarons, brownies, magic bars, and more.

Filter by

Clear

Availability

Availability

12 results

Clear

In stock 3
Out of stock 9

Price

Price

12 results

Clear

$

–

$

Sort by Featured

Sort by

Featured
Best Selling
Title, A-Z
Title, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new

Clear all

pumpkin pie tarts order online

Spiced Pumpkin Tarts

Blue sheep bake shop

Thanksgiving 2021 Signature Cake - Ombre Waves

Blue sheep bake shop

Thanksgiving 2021 Signature Cake - Art Deco

Blue sheep bake shop

Thanksgiving 2021 Signature Cupcakes - Half Dozen

Blue sheep bake shop

Thanksgiving French Macaron Set

Blue sheep bake shop

Thanksgiving French Macarons & Signature Cupcakes

$58.50 Regular price $60.00

apple ice cream pie

Apple Ice Cream Pie - 8"

rosella nutella cookie pie

Rosella Nutella Cookie Pie 8" (4 days notice)

chocolate chip bomba cookies

Chocolate Chip Bomba Cookies

thanks giving signature cookie sampler box

Thanksgiving 2021 Signature Cookie Sampler Box

Reese's STUFFED PB Cookie

Crème Brûlée Ice Cream Pie - 8"

Access Denied

IMPORTANT! If you’re a store owner, please make sure you have Customer accounts enabled in your Store Admin, as you have customer based locks set up with EasyLockdown app. Enable Customer Accounts

Get updates

Contact and Policies

orders@bluesheepbakeshop.com
(908) 393-1824
9 Division St, Somerville NJ
Terms of Service
Refund policy
Sitemap
Custom Order Contract
Signature Cake Contract/Policy

Discover the Blue Sheep experience

Discover Blue Sheep Bake Shop, your go-to destination for exquisite, handcrafted custom cakes, birthday cakes, cupcakes, French macarons, homemade ice cream, and pastries. Each of our cakes and creations is a fusion of premium ingredients, artistic design, and a dash of love, ensuring a delightful experience with every bite. Specializing in custom cakes and birthday cakes for all occasions, we're here to turn your celebrations into memorable events. Located in downtown Somerville NJ, in the heart of Somerset County.

Copyright © 2025 Blue Sheep Bake Shop. Ecommerce Software by Shopify