pickup icon

******* PLEASE READ - CAKES ARE BOOKED UNTIL FEB 24TH*******

Search
Loading...
Cart

Order online! Shop Valentine's as well as birthday cakes, cupcakes, French macarons, brownies, and more.

Signature Birthday Cakes

Celebrate birthdays and special occasions with our home made ice cream cakes! Order ice cream cakes online and pick up in Somerville NJ.

Bakery Menu - Order Online!

Moderately priced, gorgeous, & delicious birthday cakes & celebration cakes. Order birthday cakes online and pick up in Somerville NJ!

Ice Cream Cakes

Indulge in our gourmet cookies, brownies, French macarons, and dessert bars. Order online and pick up in Somerville NJ!

Discover Custom Cakes By Blue Sheep Bake Shop

Create the perfect centerpiece for your special occasion with a custom cake from Blue Sheep Bake Shop. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, welcoming a new baby with a beautiful baby shower cake, honoring a bride-to-be with an elegant bridal shower cake, or making your wedding day unforgettable with a stunning wedding cake, we have you covered. Don't forget the groom's cake for that extra personal touch! Our expertly crafted custom cakes are designed to match your vision and theme, ensuring a delicious and memorable experience for every celebration.

Send us an inquiry!

Gluten Sensitive Cakes, Ice Cream Cakes, & Decorated Cookies!

Cheesecakes, Crumb Cakes, Tres Leches

Delicious tres leches, crumb cakes, italian rainbow cakes, strawberry shortcakes, and more! Order cakes online and pick up in Somerville NJ!

Corporate Gifting & Catering

Delight your clients and employees with our customizable corporate branded desserts, perfect for elevating business events, gifting, and corporate catering needs.

Decorated Sugar Cookies

Make your events unforgettable with our beautifully decorated sugar cookie favors, personalized for weddings, birthdays, and corporate gatherings, adding a sweet and stylish touch to any celebration.

Testimonials

I cannot even begin to put into words how absolutely amazing the cake Karin and Blue Sheep created for my bridal shower was! It was a wonderland tea party theme, and the cake was the show stopper! Everyone’s jaws were on the floor, but not only that, it was absolutely delicious! One of the best tasting cakes ever. I won’t stop talking about the cake and all Blue Sheep did to make my day incredible! Even the delivery was there early and so helpful!!! Thank you x10000. The pics speak for themselves!

Lauren S.

My experience at blue sheep bake shop could not have been better I walked in and a very nice young man was extremely helpful asking me whether or not I have been there before, I told him I have and that I wanted to look around at all the goodies! when I was ready very pleasant young lady with a very bright smile offered to help me. It was very difficult making my mind up she told me to take my time and was so sweet! She boxed up my cupcakes and told me to have a wonderful night. I cannot wait to come back and try the bananas foster cupcake and some of their delicious ice cream !! Thank you for such wonderful service!! And AMAZING CUPCAKES I’m hooked!!
P.S. so far death by chocolate is my favorite!!

Barbara B.

The most beautiful and totally delicious cakes and ice cream cakes! They have so many other desserts you can try too that never disappoint. Highly recommend!

Brittany S.